Owen’s Argument 4: Christ died for His Sheep
P1: Scriptures divides men into two categories: sheep and goats
P2: Scriptures teach Christ died for the sheep
P3: Statements saying Christ died for one of the groups loose there meaning if He died for the other group
C1: Therefore, Christ died not for the goats
Scriptures Cited by Owen
A bunch, which divided men into to categories those that will be saved and those that will be lost. He also quotes a few passages, such as John 10:11 & 15, which say Christ died for His sheep.
P3 is false. My saying I enjoy action moves does not imply that I don’t enjoy comedies. Paul’s statement that Christ died for him (Galatians 2:20) doesn’t loose it’s meaning if Christ died for other people as well.
Reason 3 of the top ten reasons why Christ died for all demonstrates that Christ died for those that ultimately perish: